› Shear Flow and Shear Center Simulator Back
Structural Mechanics Simulator

Shear Flow and Shear Center of a Thin-Walled Open Section — C-Channel

Visualises the shear flow q(s)=VQ(s)/I in a C-section and the shear center e, the load point that produces no twist. Vary web height, flange width, thickness and shear force to see how the shear center moves outside the section.

Parameters
Web height h
mm
Flange width b
mm
Wall thickness t
mm
Shear force V
kN

A C-section with the same wall thickness t in the flanges and the web is assumed. The shear-center distance e is measured from the web centerline.

Results
—
Max shear flow q_max (neutral axis)
—
Max shear stress τ_max (neutral axis)
—
Applied shear force V
—
Second moment of area I_x
Real-time visualisation of the shear flow q(s)
0.00
q(s) at the probe [N/mm]
0.00
τ(s) at the probe [MPa]
UF
Probe segment
Low q Medium High q (max = neutral axis) Probe Shear center e

Left: the midline of the C-section coloured by the magnitude of the shear flow (q=0 at the free ends → q_max at mid-web). White arrows show the flow direction (upper-flange free end → web → lower-flange free end). Right: the q(s) distribution and the current probe position.

Theory & Key Formulas

When a transverse shear force V acts on a thin-walled open section, a shear flow q(s) runs along the midline of the section. Its value at any point s is the first moment of area Q(s) between that point and the free end, divided by the second moment of area I and multiplied by V.

Basic shear flow. Q(s) is the area moment along the midline, I is the section's I_x:

$$q(s) = \frac{V\,Q(s)}{I}$$

I_x of the C-section (uniform thickness t, web height h, flange width b):

$$I_x = \frac{t\,h^3}{12} + \frac{b\,t\,h^2}{2}$$

Peak shear flows in the flange (at the junction) and in the web (at mid-height):

$$q_{\text{flange,max}} = \frac{V\,t\,h\,b}{2I}$$ $$q_{\text{web,max}} = \frac{V}{I}\!\left(\frac{b\,t\,h}{2}+\frac{t\,h^2}{8}\right)$$

Shear-center distance e from the web centerline (no-twist load point):

$$e = \frac{b^2\,h^2\,t}{4\,I} \;=\; \frac{3\,b^2}{h+6b}$$

If the transverse load V passes through this point e, it exactly balances the moment of the flange shear flows q(s) and the beam responds in pure bending without twisting.

About the Thin-Walled Open-Section Shear Flow and Shear Center Simulator

🙋
When a C-channel is used as a beam, I heard that it twists even though the load is placed right above the web. Is that true?
🎓
It is. A C-section is not symmetric left-to-right, so the "load point that causes no twist" is somewhere other than the middle of the web. That point is called the shear center. Look at the red × in the simulator: it sits to the left of the web centerline (the vertical line in the section drawing), outside the section. With the defaults (h=200, b=100, t=5) it is a full 37.5 mm outside the web.
🙋
Why does the load point end up outside the section like that?
🎓
The shear flow in the flanges is the cause. When a transverse load V is applied, the upper and lower flanges carry shear flows in opposite directions, and these create a twisting moment about the middle of the web. In the graph on the right you can see the parts at the left and right ends (UF and LF) rising linearly from 0 to q_J – that is the flange q. If the load sits right above the web there is nothing to cancel the moment produced by the flange q, so the beam twists. To cancel it, the load has to act at a point some distance away from the web – the shear center.
🙋
If I make the flange width b larger, the shear-center distance e keeps growing. Making the web height h larger shrinks it instead.
🎓
Exactly. The formula is $e = 3b^2/(h+6b)$: it goes with the square of b, so longer flanges push the shear center dramatically outward. A tall C (large h) is dominated by the bending resistance of the web, so e becomes relatively small. This is why practitioners say "never put a load directly on a C-runner". Angles and Z-sections follow the same logic: any open section without a symmetry axis has its shear center shifted away from the centroid.
🙋
So how is this handled in real designs? Passing the load through a point outside the section sounds hard.
🎓
There are three classic remedies. First, weld a bracket (outstanding plate) outside the web so the load passes through the shear center. Second, pair two channels back to back to form an I-shape (a symmetric section). Third, close the section: joining the flange tips with a thin plate turns it into a box tube and the torsional stiffness jumps by hundreds of times (the world of Bredt's formula). Welding a hat panel onto a C-section side member in a car body to close it is exactly this third remedy.

Frequently Asked Questions

The centroid is the area centre of the cross-section and serves as the reference point for axial force and bending moment. The shear center is the point through which a transverse load produces no twist; it is a different point determined from the moment balance of the shear flows. For doubly symmetric sections (circle, square, I) the two coincide, but for sections with at most one axis of symmetry such as C, Z and angle sections they do not. The shear center always lies on an axis of symmetry, but its position along that axis has to be found from the shear-flow calculation.
The torsion constant of an open section is J = (1/3)Σbt³, which depends only on the cube of the thickness t. For the same area, a closed section has J = 4A²/∮(ds/t), which scales with the square of the enclosed area A, giving typically hundreds to thousands of times the torsional stiffness of an open section. For example, a 200×100×5 mm C-section and the same section closed into a box tube differ in torsional stiffness by a factor of about 800 (J_open=(1/3)·400·5³≈1.67×10⁴ mm⁴, J_closed=4·(200·100)²/(600/5)≈1.33×10⁷ mm⁴). This is why structures where torsion matters (car bodies, bridge girders, cranes) use closed sections as a rule.
An I-section is doubly symmetric, so its shear center coincides with the centroid on the web centerline. A Z-section is point-symmetric (it maps onto itself under a 180° rotation), so its shear center also coincides with the centroid. An angle (L-section) is a little special: its shear center lies near the intersection of the two legs. As a general rule, sections with two axes of symmetry have coincident points, while sections with only one axis (C, T, hat) have a shear center displaced along that axis from the centroid.
When a thin-walled open section is modelled with beam (frame) elements, most general-purpose solvers (Abaqus, ANSYS, Nastran) accept the shear-center offset as a section property. If the load is applied at a node on the web centerline, the solver computes the twist about the shear center automatically. If instead the section is modelled at full scale with shell or 3D solid elements, the shear center is reproduced naturally. The point to watch with beam elements is whether the manual requires the node to be placed at the shear center or at the centroid; putting the nodes at the centroid by mistake misinterprets the loads and boundary conditions and the results can be far off.

Real-World Applications

Automotive frame and side-member design: C-sections (including hat channels) are widely used for weight saving, but left open their torsional stiffness is extremely low and the body deformation in cornering would be unacceptable. The standard practice is to weld a floor panel or another hat section onto the bottom to close the section, raising the torsional stiffness by more than 100 times. Understanding the relation between the load point and the shear center is prerequisite knowledge for positioning reinforcements and designing weld lines.

Secondary members in steel buildings and cold-formed steel: Light-gauge C-sections (lipped channels) used as purlins and girts inevitably twist when they carry the roof load directly. In design practice the twist is restrained with tie-rods at mid-span of the secondary members, or Z-sections are adopted to soften the torsional behaviour.

Aircraft spar and stringer design: In aircraft structures, made of open sections thinned to the limit for weight saving, shear-flow calculation and buckling analysis are central to the design. The basics of open sections covered by this simulator are prerequisite knowledge for solving the shear-flow distribution in the "multi-cell closed sections" formed by skin and stringers.

Arm structures of robots and industrial machinery: Open sections (C- and U-channels) are attractive for lightening long arms, but if the load from the gripping point is offset from the shear center the arm twists and the tip positioning accuracy is lost. Designers therefore locate the shear center and deliberately align the mounting brackets of drive units and payloads with it.

Common Misconceptions and Pitfalls

The most common misconception is assuming that "the shear center must lie inside the section (within the material)". For a one-sided open section such as a C, the shear center almost always lies in "space with no material", i.e. outside the web on the side opposite the flanges. In the simulator too you can see the red × outside the outline of the section. It is a mathematical virtual point, and applying a load there directly requires a physical device such as an outstanding bracket. "If it is outside there is no way to load it" is the honest view on the shop floor, which is exactly why closing or symmetrising the section is chosen.

The next most common is the mistaken belief that "increasing the flange width b relieves the torsion problem". Try increasing b in the simulator – the shear-center distance e grows and the torsion problem gets worse. As the formula $e = 3b^2/(h+6b)$ shows, it grows with the square of b. Enlarging the flanges to raise the bending stiffness has the side effect of increasing the sensitivity to torsion. This is a typical example of the structural-design difficulty that "bending and torsion cannot be optimised independently".

Finally, note that the e shown by this simulator is an approximation that assumes "uniform thickness" and "thin-walled theory applied along the midlines of flanges and web". Real C-sections depart from this idealisation in several ways: there is a radius at the flange root, the thickness varies along the section, lips (return flanges) are added, and so on. In actual design, refer to the tables of shear-center positions for standard sections in codes such as JIS or AISI, or run an FEM analysis with a shell-element model to be sure. Use this simulator as an educational tool for grasping the principle and the feel of the behaviour.

How to Use

  1. Enter the web height h, flange width b and wall thickness t in mm (all midline dimensions). The C-section drawing updates immediately
  2. Set the shear force V in kN; the shear flow q(s)=V·Q(s)/I_x is computed automatically from thin-walled open-section theory
  3. Read q_max (mid-web), τ_max and I_x in the live results, the junction value q_J on the graph, and the shear-center distance e from the web centerline at the red × in the section drawing
  4. The yellow probe travels automatically along the midline and shows q(s), τ(s) and the segment (UF/Web/LF) at its position; use the pause, restart and speed buttons to control it

Worked Example

C-channel: H=200 mm, B=75 mm, t=6.5 mm, shear force V=50 kN. Second moment of area I_x = t·h³/12 + b·t·h²/2 ≈ 1408 cm⁴. Peak flange shear flow at the junction q_flange = V·t·h·b/(2I) ≈ 173.1 N/mm; shear flow at mid-web q_web = (V/I)·(b·t·h/2 + t·h²/8) ≈ 288.5 N/mm (τ_max = q_web/t ≈ 44.4 MPa). Shear-center distance e = 3b²/(h+6b) ≈ 26.0 mm (outside the web). A load applied at this point produces no twist.

Practical Notes