Integrates crack growth with the Paris law from the initial crack a₀ to the critical crack size, and automatically calculates the total life and an inspection interval equal to the cycles from the NDI detectable size a_det to the critical size divided by a safety factor. An animation shows the crack growing.
Parameters
Fracture toughness KIC (MPa√m)
MPa√m
Design stress σ (MPa)
MPa
Stress ratio R
Geometry factor F
Initial crack a₀ (mm)
mm
Paris coefficient C (×10⁻¹²)
da/dN = C·(ΔK)^m [m/cycle, MPa√m]
Paris exponent m
Safety factor SF
NDI detectable size a_det (mm)
mm
While paused, moving a slider updates the results immediately.
Results
—
N cycles
—
Crack length a [mm]
—
ΔK [MPa√m]
—
Remaining life [cycles]
—
Critical a_crit [mm]
—
Total life Nf [cycles]
—
Inspection interval [cycles] (a_det→a_crit divided by SF)
What Are Damage Tolerance Design, Residual Strength and Inspection Intervals?
🙋
What is "damage tolerance design"? Isn't it actually dangerous to assume that defects exist?
🎓
Roughly speaking, it is the idea of "designing so that the structure is safe even with a crack". The main wing of an airliner, for example, is designed so that even if a tiny crack exists from manufacture, there is enough time to inspect it many times before it grows to a dangerous size. Make the "Initial crack a₀" smaller or larger in this simulator and see how the life changes.
🙋
Really? So "residual strength" is the strength with a crack in it? The bigger the crack, the weaker it gets?
🎓
Exactly! Residual strength is σ_rs = KIC/(F√(πa)): the larger the crack, the lower the stress needed to break the part. The crack length at which it falls to the design stress σ is the critical crack size a_crit. Raising the "Fracture toughness KIC" from 50 to 100 increases a_crit four-fold, from about 28 mm to about 113 mm, and the total life Nf also grows. A tougher material keeps its strength higher for the same crack size.
🙋
I see! So how is the "inspection interval" decided? There's a parameter called "NDI detectable size a_det".
🎓
Good catch. An inspection reliably finds cracks above a certain size but may miss smaller ones. That limiting size is a_det . The simulator calculates the number of cycles for the crack to grow from a_det to the critical size a_crit and divides it by the safety factor SF to give the inspection interval. With the defaults (SF = 2) it is about 284,000 cycles; setting SF to 4 makes it more conservative (shorter), about 142,000 cycles. Ifa_det is made larger (assuming a less capable inspection method), the interval shortens sharply. Try it!
Frequently Asked Questions
C and m are constants that depend on the material and environment, and are generally taken from test data such as ASTM E647 or from the literature. The defaults in this tool are C = 3×10⁻¹² and m = 3 (da/dN in m/cycle, ΔK in MPa√m), but these are only guide values for exploring the tool. For a real assessment, use test values obtained for the actual material, environment and stress ratio.
The critical crack size in this tool is the theoretical value that satisfies the fracture condition for the given KIC and stress. The "Safety factor SF" is used only for the inspection interval (the a_det→a_crit cycles divided by SF); it is not applied to a_crit or the total life Nf. If you also need a margin on crack size, evaluate with a lower KIC or a higher stress.
This tool does not calculate the POD curve itself. From the POD curve of the inspection method you use, find the crack size a₉₀/₉₅ corresponding to 90% probability of detection (95% confidence) and enter it as the "NDI detectable size a_det". The tool then calculates the cycles from that size to the critical crack size with the Paris law and shows them, divided by the safety factor, as the inspection interval.
For aircraft, F values for finite-width plates or around rivet holes are used for surface and through cracks. For pressure vessels, the stress distribution in a cylindrical or spherical shell under internal pressure and the F value of a semi-elliptical surface crack are chosen. In this tool you enter the geometry factor F directly as a number (for example F = 1.0 for a centre through crack in an infinite plate and F ≈ 1.12 for an edge crack in a semi-infinite plate). F actually changes as the crack grows, but this tool treats it as constant.
Real-World Applications
Aircraft structures (FAR 25.571):Essential for the design and maintenance planning of primary structure such as airliner wings and fuselages. Manufacturing defects and accidental damage are assumed, and inspection intervals are set so that cracks can be checked in scheduled inspections (such as D checks) before they grow to a critical size, ensuring safety.
Power plants and pressure vessels (ASME Sec. XI):Piping and boilers in nuclear and thermal power plants. The growth of fatigue cracks during operation is evaluated and used as basic data for deciding plant inspection intervals and remaining life.
Bridges and infrastructure (AASHTO):Used to manage the growth of fatigue cracks at welds in steel bridges and similar structures. The cyclic stresses from traffic loading are entered to evaluate quantitatively the time until the next detailed inspection.
Pre-processing for detailed CAE analysis:Before using specialist software such as NASGRO or AFGROW, it supports engineers' early studies as a sensitivity-analysis tool showing how design parameters affect the overall life and inspection plan.
Common Misconceptions and Points to Note
There are a few points to watch out for when you start using this tool. The first is"the initial crack size a₀ is not the smallest size that inspection can find". a₀ is "the initial defect size assumed in design that may remain after being missed in manufacturing inspection". The smaller a₀ is assumed, the longer the calculated life, so making it optimistically small is on the unsafe side. For example, changing a₀ from 1 mm to 0.5 mm with the defaults increases the total life Nf from about 890,000 to about 1,340,000 cycles. It is important to base it on the size that inspection could miss.
The second is thatthe Paris law accurately describes only the "intermediate" crack growth region. In the early region where the crack is very small, and in the fast region just before fracture, the growth rate departs from the Paris law. So the life calculated by the tool is only a guide, and the behaviour near a₀ and near a_crit needs separate study. In practice, it is essential to choose the Paris coefficient C and exponent m from experimental data.
The third is the reality that"the stress range Δσ is not constant". For simplicity the tool takes a constant value, but real aircraft and bridges see load magnitudes that vary with take-offs, landings, typhoons and so on. Under such variable-amplitude loading, effects such as "retardation due to overloads" occur, and in some cases life cannot be evaluated simply by integrating the Paris law. A realistic approach is to start with a sensitivity analysis at constant stress and then consider the effects of complex load histories based on the results.
Enter the "Fracture toughness KIC" and the "Design stress σ" (the maximum stress of the cyclic load), and set the "Stress ratio R" (σmin/σmax, 0–0.7). The stress range is calculated as Δσ = σ(1−R)
Set the "Geometry factor F" and the "Initial crack a₀", and match the Paris law "Coefficient C (×10⁻¹²)" and "Exponent m" to the material's test data
Enter the "NDI detectable size a_det" and the "Safety factor SF"; the critical crack size a_crit, the total life Nf and the inspection interval update in real time, and the animation shows the crack growing
Worked Example
With the defaults (KIC = 50 MPa√m, σ = 150 MPa, R = 0.1, F = 1.12, a₀ = 1 mm, C = 3×10⁻¹², m = 3, SF = 2, a_det = 2 mm): Δσ = 150×(1−0.1) = 135 MPa and a_crit = (50/(1.12×150))²/π ≈ 28.19 mm. Integrating the Paris law from a₀ to a_crit gives a total life Nf ≈ 889,000 cycles; reaching a_det = 2 mm takes about 321,000 cycles, so the inspection interval is (889,000 − 321,000)/2 ≈ 284,000 cycles (in agreement with the analytical solution for m = 3).
Practical Notes
The stress ratio R is the service load ratio σmin/σmax. This tool reflects R only through Δσ = σ(1−R) and does not include the change of the Paris constants themselves with R (handled by the Walker or NASGRO equations, for example)
a_det varies greatly with inspection method, location and conditions. Use an a₉₀/₉₅ based on demonstrated data, and check that a larger a_det shortens the inspection interval sharply
The Paris law holds only in the intermediate region where ΔK is well above the threshold ΔK_th and K_max is well below KIC. At both ends the actual growth rate departs from it, so treat the life from this tool as a guide