Snap-through Analysis
Snap-through: Theoretical Foundations
What is Snap-Through?
Professor, what kind of phenomenon is snap-through?
Snap-through is a phenomenon where a shallow arch or dome inverts after exceeding the peak load (limit point). The limit point is passed using the Riks method (arc-length method).
Summary
Roof Dome Snap-Through: Two Stable States
Snap-through is a rapid transition of a "bi-stable system" where a single structure possesses two stable equilibrium states. This phenomenon, where a thin spherical shell inverts from "convex" to "concave" under external pressure, was analyzed for shells by Biezeno and Hencky in 1934. Snap fasteners (clothing snaps) are a familiar example that intentionally uses this phenomenon; the "click" action when pressed is snap-through itself.
Computational Methods for Snap-through
Riks Method Settings
Summary
Snap-Through Tracking via Arc Length Method
Load-displacement paths containing snap-through cannot be tracked with normal load control. The arc length method developed by Riks (1979) and Crisfield (1981) simultaneously controls load and displacement, enabling tracking even in negative stiffness regions. By controlling load steps with Δl (arc length), a continuous analysis path is obtained up to the post-snap-through equilibrium shape. Abaqus's RIKS STEP implements this.
Snap-through in Practice
Practical Checklist
Two-Stable State Design of Snap Fasteners
The most familiar practical example of snap-through is push-pull connectors (e.g., by Amphenol) or binding leaf springs. Spring steel plates 0.3–0.5mm thick are designed to have two stable states, creating a click sensation. In mass-produced part design, the arc-length method in ANSYS Mechanical is used to understand the snap-back point on the load-displacement curve, and mold adjustments are made with 0.02mm precision.
Snap-through: Software & Solver Comparison
Tools
Abaqus *STATIC, RIKS is standard. All solvers support the arc-length method.
Each Vendor's Implementation of Arc-Length Method: Riks Method and Its Variants
The arc-length method for snap-through analysis was proposed by E. Riks in 1972, but derivative implementations differ by solver. MSC Nastran uses the CRISFIELD spherical arc-length method, ABAQUS uses the Modified Riks method, ANSYS uses the Cylindrical Arc-Length method. A 2019 comparative study in the International Journal of Solids reported up to a 12% difference in load-displacement curves between ABAQUS and ANSYS for post-buckling analysis of 2D shell structures.
Advanced Technology
Advanced Research
Snap-Through Buckling: Deployment Mechanism of Space Telescopes
The snap-through phenomenon gained attention in the design of the solar panel deployment mechanism for the ESA Herschel Space Telescope (launched 2009). The design intentionally used snap-through to actuate a lock mechanism during deployment. As a successful case study, post-buckling analysis using ABAQUS's arc-length method (Riks method) predicted the deployment force within a 5% error margin, which was published.
Snap-through: Common Issues & Debugging
Troubles
When Convergence Stops with the Arc-Length Method
When the arc-length method fails to converge at a specific load level, it's often because the increment arc length Δl is too large and "jumps over" the snap-through point. First, reduce Δl to 1/5 and re-run the analysis. Also, increase the iteration count to 50–100 and check the residual norm trend. To improve convergence, it's effective to check the minimum buckling load with a linear buckling analysis before starting and set the initial arc length to 5–10% of that value.
Related Topics
Experience the theory firsthand with the interactive simulator for this field
All Simulators