Fretting Fatigue
Fretting Fatigue: Theoretical Foundations
What is Fretting Fatigue?
Professor, what is fretting fatigue?
Fretting is microscopic relative slip (a few μm to tens of μm) at contact surfaces. This slip causes surface damage and promotes the nucleation of fatigue cracks. Examples include shrink-fit parts, bolt holes, and blade dovetails.
Mechanism of Fretting Fatigue
1. Microscopic slip destroys the surface oxide film
2. Fresh surfaces are exposed → re-oxidation → generation of oxidative wear particles
3. Wear particles act as stress concentrators → crack nucleation
4. Crack propagation under multiaxial stress field from contact pressure + friction force
Evaluation with FEM
1. Contact FEM (with friction) — Calculates stress distribution and microscopic slip amount on the contact surface
2. Fatigue evaluation using the critical plane method — Multiaxial fatigue criteria such as Fatemi-Socie
3. SWT (Smith-Watson-Topper) parameter — Standard index for fretting fatigue
Summary
Micro-wear at Turbine Blade Fastening Points
Fretting fatigue occurs at contact points where microscopic relative slip repeats. In aircraft engine blade root sections, even a relative displacement of only a few μm during vibration, combined with a contact pressure of 300 MPa, can reduce the fatigue limit by more than 50%. GE analyzed this problem in the 1980s and optimized the dovetail shape.
Computational Methods for Fretting Fatigue
FEM for Fretting Fatigue
1. Contact FEM — Contact with friction. Accurately resolves the micro-slip region (stick-slip boundary)
2. Contact surface mesh — Very fine (element size about 1/10 of the contact zone)
3. Multiaxial stress → Life prediction using the critical plane method
Summary
FEM Evaluation Method for Fretting Fatigue
In fretting fatigue analysis, the combination of shear stress and normal stress at the contact area is key. The Ruiz-Meyer parameter (shear stress × relative displacement) was proposed as an index in the 1980s and remains valid today. In FEM, setting the friction coefficient of contact elements to 0.4–0.8 to reproduce the micro-slip state is crucial for accuracy.
Fretting Fatigue in Practice
Fretting Fatigue in Practice
Turbine blade dovetail joints, bolt hole seat surfaces, shrink-fit shafts.
Practical Checklist
Fretting Countermeasures for Bolted Joints
The area around bolt holes in aircraft structures is a typical location for fretting fatigue. For the Boeing 737, a combination of phosphate coating and grease was used as a fretting countermeasure at fuselage panel fastening points, extending fatigue life by 1.5 times. In practice, surface treatment and preload optimization are the most effective countermeasures.
Fretting Fatigue: Software & Solver Comparison
Tools
ANSYS Mechanical Contact Fatigue Module
Since ANSYS Mechanical 2020, the contact stress output function for fretting fatigue evaluation has been enhanced. Using the automatic Ruiz parameter calculation function allows batch evaluation of fatigue risk for hundreds of contact nodes. Airbus used this function to complete the engine mount design for the A320neo 40% faster than before.
Advanced Technologies
Advanced Fretting Fatigue: Modern Research & Trends in Fretting
Fretting Suppression by DLC Coating
Diamond-Like Carbon (DLC) coating can reduce the friction coefficient to below 0.1 and improve fretting fatigue life by 5–10 times. Kawasaki Heavy Industries introduced DLC treatment for helicopter rotor hub parts in the 2010s, successfully doubling maintenance intervals. A film thickness of 2μm provides sufficient effect.
Fretting Fatigue: Common Issues & Debugging
Fretting Troubles
Unexpected Early Failure of Coupling Shafts
Fretting fatigue is easily overlooked because surface damage is small. If a shaft coupling fails at 30% of its design life, SEM observation of the fracture surface reveals reddish-brown oxide powder characteristic of fretting. In addition to checking torque fluctuation range and shaft diameter, be sure to record the surface roughness Ra value of the contact surface.
Experience the theory firsthand with the interactive simulator for this field
All Simulators